Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Amplifier Unusual Loud "Shots"

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Amplifier Unusual Loud "Shots"

    Hey all once again ,

    A day after jamming with my Marshall Valvestate VS100 (That was working like a charm) , I noticed a constant sooshy-windy sound that gradually (2-3 hours) mutated into a very loud crackle-rumbly sound (I still get guitar sound & the noise is independant from the volume),it literally makes your guts jump , I started 'chopsticking' the amp as I usually do , noticed that nothing seemed to trigger this sound

    These loud rumbles are 100% random , whether the volume is on 0 or the guitar unplugged - also noticed that it makes a brutal loud pop when switching to the clean channel. (it never did this until today)


    Can these random loud crackly/rumbly/poppy noises be caused by failing capacitors? I wouldn't say that it's a resistor...

    Any thoughts?

  • #2
    VS100 Manual & Schematics attached

    Originally posted by GasMask52 View Post
    Hey all once again ,

    A day after jamming with my Marshall Valvestate VS100 (That was working like a charm) , I noticed a constant sooshy-windy sound that gradually (2-3 hours) mutated into a very loud crackle-rumbly sound (I still get guitar sound & the noise is independant from the volume),it literally makes your guts jump , I started 'chopsticking' the amp as I usually do , noticed that nothing seemed to trigger this sound

    These loud rumbles are 100% random , whether the volume is on 0 or the guitar unplugged - also noticed that it makes a brutal loud pop when switching to the clean channel. (it never did this until today)


    Can these random loud crackly/rumbly/poppy noises be caused by failing capacitors? I wouldn't say that it's a resistor...

    Any thoughts?
    After downloading the Schematics and User Manual (which I've attached here), I'd start by first unplugging the one Preamp tube (power down first, of course), then, with the tube removed, power back up to see if the problem is still occurring. If so, we know it's not the tube, and so plug that back in. I didn't see the Line Out jack could serve as a Power Amp Input jack, disconnecting the preamp, so you can't isolate the preamp circuit from the power amp circuit. If the Effects Send/Return jacks are Always in circuit, you could try plugging a shorting plug or a short patch cable into the Return jack to see if that changes anything. We're trying to isolate the preamp section from the power amp section to find WHERE the problem is occurring.

    Assuming no success there either, power down, and unplug ribbon cable Conn 2. That WILL isolate the Power Amp circuit from the Preamp Circuit, and only contains the rear panel Effects Send/Return jacks, footswitch jack and Power Amp input circuit. Power back up with it disconnected to see if the problem continues or not. If not, then unplug/reconnect both the Conn 1 and Conn 2 ribbon cables. Two main cables.....Conn 1 and Conn 2. Exercise those connections a few times to see if after doing so, anything has changed. If not, then I normally remove the rear panel PCB for close inspection for solder joint fractures. I haven't seen the insides of this amp, so I don't physically know how difficult it is to pull the amp apart for inspection of all the PCB's. You've already been probing with chopsticks without success, which often finds the problem components having intermittent solder joint connections.

    Pounding on the chassis to see if the problem is activated by vibration....usually caused by solder joint connections within. It looks like the Reverb circuit is a traditional 'tank', instead of a solid state reverb circuit. I'd disconnect the tank Output from the amp's return circuit to see if it's involved.

    If none of these reveal where the problem is, then you're into measurements with test gear to find where the fault is. I'd begin with the power supply circuits. We don't know your skill level in testing/service, as at this point, you're dealing with some high voltages and shock hazards.

    Marshall-VS100R-100W-Schematic.pdf

    vs100r-vs102r-vs100rh-manual-479345.pdf
    Last edited by nevetslab; 05-16-2020, 08:47 PM.
    Logic is an organized way of going wrong with confidence

    Comment


    • #3
      Thank you nevetslab

      No problemo , I'm 400% familiar with this amp , inside out, from the very first component to the last
      Before searching for help on this forum I already did a few tests that I forgot to mention :

      *I previously repaired this amp - it used to turn on if hitted with no power source available - it was the power filter caps , they were loose , re-soldered them

      *Tested it without the ECC83 , noise is still there but at a very low volume (obviously)

      *Reverb tank was always disconnected during tests

      *Weirdly (noticed this on all 4 VS100 that I own) disconnecting one of the CON molex connectors will disengage the power, like if ALL CONs must be connected for the amp to power up

      *Noticed a static sound (different and independent from the main crackly noise) while poking C38 & IC2 (on PreAmp) , re-soldered & replaced , but no difference, it still makes static noise when touched, I guess it's "normal" , no cold solder joints on them

      *I read that many people that had my same issue, solved it by replacing all caps - this sounds fishy, it doesn't sound like a cap problem to me - after all , while I was 'chopsticking' the caps , nothing got triggered , the crackly swarm of bees was random and nearly constant

      Comment


      • #4
        OK....you're a lot further along with these than I am. I've only been inside a couple of their Valve State amps, though not this one. I mostly service JCM 800's, 900's, 2000's and TSL heads and combo's, with several others that's in our rental inventory at CenterStaging in Burbank, CA.

        I've certainly come across similar symptoms on lots of gear. Some are component based, others (seemingly the majority) have been from solder joint fractures or tubes. It does seem like a power supply related problem. You could selectively short out different circuits, beginning with shorting the input to the power amp stage, such as shorting R4 input bias resistor to T1 input side of the diff amp stage. Then, I'd work backwards to preceeding stages to see if you can isolate where the noise source is (assuming it's NOT power supply sourced). With no signal applied, this shouldn't cause any problems in the analog signal path by shorting the IC outputs. Or, short with a 10 ohm resistor to ground.
        Logic is an organized way of going wrong with confidence

        Comment


        • #5
          Rather than suspecting capacitors or resistors, I would first suspect the active components (transistors and IC's).
          Freeze spray is a big help for faults like this.
          "Everything is better with a tube. I have a customer with an all-tube pacemaker. His heartbeat is steady, reassuring and dependable, not like a modern heartbeat. And if it goes wrong he can fix it himself. You can't do that with SMD." - Mick Bailey

          Comment


          • #6
            I have another thought. Since you own four of these VS100 amps, that gives you modules that you can swap to see if you can make the problem move or stop.
            Logic is an organized way of going wrong with confidence

            Comment


            • #7
              Yep, that exactly what I did an hour ago, I swapped out a couple of boards , and I came to the conclusion that the issue is in the PreAmp - the Power Module is 100% fine

              Though I noticed that today , I literally get no output from the guitar , I just hear very light crackling , as if there's no tube, when there is

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by g1 View Post
                Rather than suspecting capacitors or resistors, I would first suspect the active components (transistors and IC's).
                Freeze spray is a big help for faults like this.
                Makes sense, I already replaced IC1 & 2 on the PreAmp , but no luck - I would start targeting specific components but I'm not that good at reading the vs100 diagram to the point where I know which components are vital for guitar output

                Comment


                • #9
                  Click image for larger version

Name:	20200517_132312.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	2.91 MB
ID:	857774


                  Click image for larger version

Name:	20200517_132507.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	2.66 MB
ID:	857775



                  These are the only visual "oddities" that I spotted till now, R43 looks weird , wouldn't say its dead/opened but it's the only resistor that looks like this

                  Under the Daughter board you can easily see the naked copper fom the cables BN1 & BU1 that connect themselves to the positive & negative spots on the power supply - would these create output problems if not soldered decently? I'll add some solder to find out

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    You really need to approach this with a divide and conquer strategy, which is what nevetslab was trying to get you to do There is no reason why simply disconnecting CON1 on the power amp board will do anything other than disconnect the the preamp that I can see. So pull it and listen. If noisy then it's on the power amp board and I'd start with the freezer spray test on the semiconductors and especially suspect T1 and T2. When freezer spray works it's great but in my experience it only works well about 25% of the time. So, if you get a negative result on T1 and T2 I'd replace them anyway. If you get a positive result, well you still replace them If silent then it's not the power amp. That said I think you already have a clue that it's in the preamp so read on...

                    You already pulled the tube and said the noise was still there but a at low volume, 'obviously'. Dunno, but that's isn't obvious to me at all. If it's before the tube it should be silent and if after then it should still still noisy. What you have is something inbetween so that has to be worth looking into. With the clean channel selected and the tube pulled, try shorting out R49 (on the input to IC3), does that stop the remaining noise? If it does I'd suspect R23 100k on the cathode of V1. If not then I'd suspect IC3 next, again freezer spray might confirm.
                    Experience is something you get, just after you really needed it.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by nickb View Post
                      You really need to approach this with a divide and conquer strategy, which is what nevetslab was trying to get you to do There is no reason why simply disconnecting CON1 on the power amp board will do anything other than disconnect the the preamp that I can see. So pull it and listen. If noisy then it's on the power amp board and I'd start with the freezer spray test on the semiconductors and especially suspect T1 and T2. When freezer spray works it's great but in my experience it only works well about 25% of the time. So, if you get a negative result on T1 and T2 I'd replace them anyway. If you get a positive result, well you still replace them If silent then it's not the power amp. That said I think you already have a clue that it's in the preamp so read on...

                      You already pulled the tube and said the noise was still there but a at low volume, 'obviously'. Dunno, but that's isn't obvious to me at all. If it's before the tube it should be silent and if after then it should still still noisy. What you have is something inbetween so that has to be worth looking into. With the clean channel selected and the tube pulled, try shorting out R49 (on the input to IC3), does that stop the remaining noise? If it does I'd suspect R23 100k on the cathode of V1. If not then I'd suspect IC3 next, again freezer spray might confirm.

                      ok nickb thanks so much, here's the deal!

                      **Disconnected CON1 from the power module - NO noise , so it's in the PreAmp

                      **Shorted out R49 , removed the ecc83 and as soon as I turned the switch on it made a loud POP sound , but NO noise/crackles after, turned it off and it made another loud pop sound. (guess that happens when R49 is removed??)

                      You reckon I should replace R23 with the coupling cap? I'll do it now

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Ok I mounted R49 back, replaced R23, now i get NO noise WITHOUT the tube, but WITH the tube i get crackling noise and no guitar output, (replaced IC3 aswell) what now?
                        Last edited by GasMask52; 05-17-2020, 05:03 PM.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          The test was to SHORT OUT R49, not remove it. Not exactly sure what you did as you say both shorted and removed. With it shorted out there's no reason for a loud pop if it didn't do it before. Let's have a sanity check. Are R49 and R23 100k on your board? If yes, what is the voltage across R23, R49 and on pin 5 of IC3?
                          Experience is something you get, just after you really needed it.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            My bad sorry - first I removed R49 to test it with a multimeter (was curious) , then I resoldered it and disconnected the lead that connects to pin 2 of IC3 (+input), removed the tube and the crackling was gone - though when I tested it with the tube in , the crackling came back - also no POP sound when I engage the power.

                            I don't feel confident enough to mesure the voltages on a live amp, I would prefer not to

                            So now we solved the issue that it crackles with no tube - but it still crackles with the tube

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              I had one of these amps with the same symptoms. The solder job from factory was horrible. After fixing all connections that were obviously bad, symptoms occurred much less but would still pop up.

                              In the end I went through the entire amp and re-soldered every connection, and that cleared it up for good.

                              Also double check the speaker quick disconnects AND the 1/4" cable/plug that connects them to the amp.
                              Last edited by garytoosweet; 05-18-2020, 04:15 AM.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X