Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Vox historians: help reading minutiae on 1960 Vox AC15 OA/031 schematic

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    Originally posted by dchang0 View Post
    I do have a question, though about the voltage on pin 6 of EF86--is it really 50V? That FEELS kinda low--of course, I don't know squat about what it's supposed to be, and I don't have an early 60s AC15 to actually measure. royaljelly says it's supposed to be 95V (but he does not mention where he got this value) in this thread: http://music-electronics-forum.com/t25383/

    Looking at Merlin's EF86 theory website, it SEEMS to me that 50V would be really low too: The Valve Wizard -Small Signal Pentode
    The curves in the middle of the page--50V is right at the very edge of where they bend. Again, I have no idea whether 50V is right or wrong--it just FEELS low...
    50V is nonsense.

    Probably a typo by the original draftsman who might have been redrawing a pencilled original, or , say, a "1" sign was lost in photocopying (which would make it a WAY more reasonable 150V) or, as a last possibility, what an old meter could have read, although really those were much better than we think today.

    I for one weaned on them, from late 60's to early 80's and even now and then, just for fun (it sure impresses customers ) even today. I even use my slide rule (a circular one to boot) which sure draws shop attendants crazy

    As the name implies, a 20k/V meter will show 20000*500 = 10M input impedance on the 500V scale, which would be used there , WAY better than the typical 1M shown by most modern digital meters (now you know why now and then I still use the old analog ones) , only a few modern ones show 10M .

    Instead of guessing, reading the Runes or a just sacrificed goat liver, why not check the ... ugh ..... datasheet?
    Such as: http://www.mif.pg.gda.pl/homepages/f...010/e/EF86.pdf

    there on page 3 we read that for 220k plate load, 2k2 cathode resistor, supply voltage 300V , screen voltage derived from that, gain is some 200X and undistorted output voltage is 53V RMS ... completely impossible with just 50V on plate which practically must be saturation voltage (DC saturation, not signal clipping).

    It certainly must have been quite higher, at least 100V or thereabouts, probably closer to 1/2 +V , simply for symmetry and max. undistorted peak to peak swing.

    It is entirely possible that Dick Denney purposefully chose 50V right at the edge of the nonlinear region.
    Mmmmhhhhh, that looks like modern day rationalization, Dick could not be interested in wonderful creamy overdrive or other modern obsessions but maximum clean power ... same as all designers in that era.

    To boot, he "chose" nothing: values are pulled straight from datasheet!!!!!!

    I guess you would do a service to (accurate) History by correcting once and forever that myth, repeated endlessly without checking.

    By the way, VERY easy to check , just build an EF86 stage with same part values, feed it proper voltage and measure

    For all the talk about modern Science, the Inquisition Vs. Galileo, the Flat Earth, yada yada yada, many are still rereading hundreds of times and endlessly arguing the old Sacred Texts while the Experiment is SO easy.

    Oh well, won't hold my breath.

    I'll put 50V as you report. If anyone else can shed light on the matter (especially with real-world measurements, although we know that wall voltages were lower in the 60s than now, and modern transformers are probably wound differently than the originals, etc.), please do.
    Don't worry about wall voltage and old transformers, just use a Variac until secondaries show 6.3VAC and 300+300VAC and forget primaries.

    And to be fair, JMI DID provide for a lot of primary taps to choose from
    Juan Manuel Fahey

    Comment


    • #32
      Awesome analysis and explanation--thanks, JM!

      Speaking of building an EF86 stage, I am just about to start building a lookalike JMI AC15 clone now. The last few parts came in yesterday (CDE WMF-series film-and-foil capacitors--some values can be hard to get). I'll be able to take those voltage measurements myself in a few weeks...

      But to some degree, this thread was really about reading the old Sacred Texts and trying to restore the piece of history that was the poorly-digitized OA/031 schematic. I could've followed sluckey's easily-legible schematic at any time if I were only interested in building.

      Comment

      Working...
      X