Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Speaker coil winding

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Speaker coil winding

    I hope this is the right place to put this. I figure winding magnet wire is winding magnet wire so there shouldn't be much difference skill wise. Is it worth it to repair speaker coils?

    Note: This thread was originally posted in the 'Tools and Coil Winding Gear' sub-forum of the 'Pickup Makers' forum.
    Last edited by Boss; 12-02-2018, 07:41 AM. Reason: added note about location change

  • #2
    I would expect, with the need to keep the coil & former perfectly circular, and the coil firmly glued in place, the skill set is much more demanding. And that's with round wire. How about winding JBL-style, flat wire, edge-on? Yikes! But - somebody's doing it somewhere, recone kits are being made & that's proof enough. I'm looking forward to what our pickup winding brain trust has to say.
    This isn't the future I signed up for.

    Comment


    • #3
      How often does the brain trust check in?

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by anchor View Post
        How often does the brain trust check in?
        Why don't you try it and report back?
        How much does a new speaker cost vs what you have to buy to repair one speaker and learn how to do it.
        Do the math.
        nosaj
        soldering stuff that's broken, breaking stuff that works, Yeah!

        Comment


        • #5
          At this stage of my understanding, I don't think it would be worth it for me. I've never worked with magnet wire. I probably don't have the tools and materials to make it worthwhile. That may not be the case for people already familiar with winding. It's why I posted here. Are you a member of the brain trust?

          Comment


          • #6
            How about this.
            English not great, but the pictures are good.

            "If Hitler invaded Hell, I would make at least a favourable reference of the Devil in the House of Commons." Winston Churchill
            Terry

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by anchor View Post
              I hope this is the right place to put this. I figure winding magnet wire is winding magnet wire so there shouldn't be much difference skill wise. Is it worth it to repair speaker coils?
              It can be done, but there´s some important differences.

              FWIW I do wind my own voice coils, but I reserve that for custom jobs, such as cloning old Jensen voice coils, using old style synthetic enamelled wire, wound on paper formers, and glued with solvent based Nitro adhesives.

              For bulk production speakers, I pay around $1 for a Chinese ready to use round copper on kapton former one, glued with high temperature epoxy and with leads precut and pretinned ... why worry?
              You can get those in the usual sizes for $2 to $5 from Ted Weber, as well as suitable cones, suspensions, and everything else.

              The few times where I was forced to rewind a voice coil still attached to the cone was wehere it was irreplaceable and removing voice coil (which to boot was odd sized) would destroy it, so ....
              And it´s not a job for the faint hearted.

              You also need to have a lathe available, better if on the same premises, because you need to make an exact size core to hold former (which is weak and flexible, paper thin) in the proper position against wire pressure , which is high because you want it tight.

              A big difference with pickup winding is that these can be (and usually are) scatter wound, with one turn mounting on others not a big deal, while voice coils are two perfect layers, period, with each turn perfectly parallel and touching those on its sides.

              And wire must be glued , of course, since it´s designed to vibrate back and forth, and push/pull a load 20 to 40 times larger than its own weight.

              Car engines and most machines are *designed* to be disassembled and reassembled, that´s why they use bolts, pins, clamps, click together, etc. so you can half disassemble a car engine, take 200 parts out, replace some component deep inside and reassemble using all of the old parts.

              Speakers on the contrary, and because of extreme weight and space considerations, are *glued* together, and are made of weak paper , cloth, foam, etc. so standard speaker repair procedure is to grab an X Acto knife, cut everything away (and junk it) , scratch old glue and reassemble with all new parts, except magnet and frame.
              Juan Manuel Fahey

              Comment


              • #8
                Thanks for the helpful posts. It looks like the choice of adhesives and glues are critical here. Where do you guys source yours? In my case, I have an 8" driver that froze. I considered using some de-oxit in the coil gap but that would leave the residue in there. Looking further, the ohm value is still in spec so the coil is probably not damaged. How would you guys approach this repair?

                Comment


                • #9
                  Search any Industrial Epoxy supplier.
                  I use Araldit but can´t tell you the original name since my supplier buys the 55 gallon drums and repacks it into 250 gram and 1 kilo cans, with his own brand.
                  But it´s the one which is thick as honey at room temperature, mixed about 1:1 which makes measurement easier, one component is honey yellowish transparent, the other is whitish translucid, and takes some 6 to 8 hours to cure at room temperatuire.
                  It cures faster at higher temperatute, say 15 minutes at 100C and you must not go over 120C or it bubbles.
                  Any knowledgeable supplier willl find it with that data (which is pretty common) or give you another brand equivalent.
                  Toluene you get in small amounts (it´s a controlled substance) from your friendly Industrial Chemist,.
                  Enamelled wire from usual suppliers, with the caveat it **MUST** be the high temperature enamel type, Class F or H or better , guaranteed 160 or 180C operation, typically used to rewind electric motors.
                  The currently popular "self soldering" type, with atoms thin enamel which evaporates at low temperatures has no place inside a speaker.
                  The polished metal cores such as shown in the (very accurate) video are custom made on a lathe.
                  I suggest using small stiff brushes to apply epoxy instead of fingertip, I am half expecting the video guy to grow a tumor there, not kidding, uncured epoxy is very aggressive, as well as Toluene (and the impurities it carries which are left behind under your skin).
                  Juan Manuel Fahey

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by anchor View Post
                    Thanks for the helpful posts. It looks like the choice of adhesives and glues are critical here. Where do you guys source yours? In my case, I have an 8" driver that froze. I considered using some de-oxit in the coil gap but that would leave the residue in there. Looking further, the ohm value is still in spec so the coil is probably not damaged. How would you guys approach this repair?
                    What driver is it? If it's nothing special just replace it and be done with it. Hate to think your asking all this for a cheap chinese speaker.

                    nosaj
                    soldering stuff that's broken, breaking stuff that works, Yeah!

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by nosaj View Post
                      What driver is it? If it's nothing special just replace it and be done with it. Hate to think your asking all this for a cheap chinese speaker.

                      nosaj
                      Jeez, lighten up.

                      I do stuff like this all the time with cheap, junk, crap stuff that is broken or non functional.

                      I got nuttin to lose and I find out how stuff is put together, and how it works.

                      If I'm successful in the "repair"... then great! plus I learned something.

                      If I'm not successful then... no big loss, it was broken anyway...
                      BUT, I still LEARNED something, and may be better prepared to tackle working on something of value.
                      If it ain't broke I'll fix it until it is...
                      I have just enough knowledge to be dangerous...

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by galaxiex View Post
                        Jeez, lighten up.

                        I do stuff like this all the time with cheap, junk, crap stuff that is broken or non functional.

                        I got nuttin to lose and I find out how stuff is put together, and how it works.

                        If I'm successful in the "repair"... then great! plus I learned something.

                        If I'm not successful then... no big loss, it was broken anyway...
                        BUT, I still LEARNED something, and may be better prepared to tackle working on something of value.
                        He has a reason
                        "Take two placebos, works twice as well." Enzo

                        "Now get off my lawn with your silicooties and boom-chucka speakers and computers masquerading as amplifiers" Justin Thomas

                        "If you're not interested in opinions and the experience of others, why even start a thread?
                        You can't just expect consent." Helmholtz

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I don't know that it is special but it seems well made. There is only a cryptic stamp of 220B. The magnet is ~135mm diameter and very strong. The basket structure is very rigid, it has tarred cloth, accordian surrounds, etc. It weighs 5 kilo. I don't think I could get similar quality for less than 100. I didn't pay for it so I don't know its origin. To get all the chemicals required will cost me ~60. A cheap replacement coil that fits might tempt me to try the repair. I'm still on the fence about it.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Let's hope he winds it.
                            I would like to see what he comes up with.
                            Of Course we need documented play by play & pictures, along the way!
                            GL,
                            T
                            "If Hitler invaded Hell, I would make at least a favourable reference of the Devil in the House of Commons." Winston Churchill
                            Terry

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by anchor View Post
                              I don't know that it is special but it seems well made. There is only a cryptic stamp of 220B. The magnet is ~135mm diameter and very strong. The basket structure is very rigid, it has tarred cloth, accordian surrounds, etc. It weighs 5 kilo. I don't think I could get similar quality for less than 100. I didn't pay for it so I don't know its origin. To get all the chemicals required will cost me ~60. A cheap replacement coil that fits might tempt me to try the repair. I'm still on the fence about it.
                              Where is your location, someone could suggest something close to you since your not in the US. Show us a picture, what did it come out of.
                              nosaj
                              soldering stuff that's broken, breaking stuff that works, Yeah!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X