Very much so, Enzo.
Bstring, suggest you concentrate more on studying transistor circuits than depending on simulators. I know too many who use a simulator as a crutch. All of the analyses that we provided in this thread were done based on circuit knowledge. I only resorted to the simulator because I was having trouble convincing the community to take a leap of faith that the schematic was wrong. I can understand that. Maybe we can all take something out of it. On the plus side, despite differing perspectives, not one flame in this entire thread. Well done.
Jcon
BTW Bstring, any spice simulator can analyze this circuit... if you know what you're doing. In this case, I needed to generate x-sistor models, and modify a model to simulate back-biased leakage. It's not rocket science, but those who use spice as a crutch will frequently get the wrong answer. Without circuit knowledge, they will not realize it.
Jcon
Bstring, suggest you concentrate more on studying transistor circuits than depending on simulators. I know too many who use a simulator as a crutch. All of the analyses that we provided in this thread were done based on circuit knowledge. I only resorted to the simulator because I was having trouble convincing the community to take a leap of faith that the schematic was wrong. I can understand that. Maybe we can all take something out of it. On the plus side, despite differing perspectives, not one flame in this entire thread. Well done.
Jcon
BTW Bstring, any spice simulator can analyze this circuit... if you know what you're doing. In this case, I needed to generate x-sistor models, and modify a model to simulate back-biased leakage. It's not rocket science, but those who use spice as a crutch will frequently get the wrong answer. Without circuit knowledge, they will not realize it.
Jcon
Comment