I think slightly more headroom. The JJ6V6S is a different tube (from a 6V6GT) - plates are more like a 6P3S, and it (going by the schematic on the JJ dadsheet) it appears to be a pentode (whereas the 6V6GT is a tetrode), - but I've never opened one up to see. Might have a go on an old one this w/e maybe if I get around to it.
Ad Widget
Collapse
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
New Tremolux 5G9 build --> input welcome!
Collapse
X
-
Tremolo Speed Range --> pot wiring
Originally posted by tubeswell View PostLog taper pots are best for vol and tone controls. Use a linear taper for the depth control and RA taper for the speed control. 3MRA will work fine. When I did mine used a NOS 2M5RA and tweeked the tapering resistor to 120k. With 3MRA, you may want to try a 150k tapering resistor (instead of 100k) to get it working closer to the original. But when you get it working we can talk more about adjusting the trem if you want.
The speed knob starts to pulsate only at position 4 or higher (before 4 it doesn’t pulsate at all!). I tried to slow down the tremolo with putting a 0.022uF instead of the 2nd 0.01uF and 0.047uF instead of the 0.033uF caps. It slows down, but still the tremolo starts to work at position 4 or higher. I have the feeling that this is not right (and that the tremolo should be even somewhat slower…).
I thought it had to do with the (tapering?) resistor on the pot. I have a 3M Reverse Audio speed pot and a 160k resistor between the left and middle lug, see my layouts. But I also tried to put the resistor between middle lug and ground, a bit like in the BF amps. But there seems to be no difference, there is still the start of the pulse at position '4' of the speed knob.
Further, what happens exactly to the speed if you change the value of the resistor? What values did you use to experiment? (I see some posts in which you state that you have experimented...)
Comment
-
Originally posted by tubeswell View PostAre you using a 12AX7 triode? What are the idle voltages?
Comment
-
V1: (1) 167VDC; (2) 0 VDC; (3) 2.7 VDC; (6) 160VDC (7) 0 VDC (8) 2.7 VDC
V2: (1) 190VDC; (2) 21 VDC; (3) 31 VDC; (6) 185VDC (7) 22 VDC (8) 31 VDC
V3: (1) 260VDC; (2) 0 VDC; (3) 1.96 VDC; (6) 390VDC (7) 260 VDC (8) 262 VDC (trem not engaged)
Further all heaters at (4&5&9) 3.3VAC
Are all the 0 Volts okay??
Speed pot dial:
Resistance Between right and middle lug ----- Between right lug and ground (so including the 160k in series)
position 1: 3.2MOhm ------- 3.39MOhm
position 2: 2.9MOhm ------- 3.1MOhm
position 3: 2.1MOhm ------- 2.3MOhm
position 4: 1.2MOhm ------- 1.4MOhm
position 5: 0.5MOhm ------- 0.6MOhm
position 6: 0.3MOhm ------- 0.5MOhm
position 7: 0.2MOhm ------- 0.4MOhm
and so on....
I have the feeling that this is not like it should... Who knows??
Comment
-
OK, I found what is happening. I have calculated the total resistance and plotted it in the following graph:
You can see that at the speed pot at dial position 4 gives the start of pulsation. The total resistance is ca. 1.4MOhm. In the original design the pot was 2MOhm. You can see now that it takes only a dial from 2 to 1.4MOhm to start working and this is within the original pot position 1 to 2. There is just an offset using the 3 MOhm of 1MOhm and this takes a few pot positions... Further the 160k is kicking in at the higher speed to prevent that the speed doesn't go mental, so it just limits the maximum speed!
Comment
-
-
Those voltages look in the ballpark.
Maybe try a 120k tapering resistor between the pot wiper and the ground. Are the other resistors in the R-C part of the LFO stage 1M? Do you have .03uF for the first cap and .01 uF for the next two?Building a better world (one tube amp at a time)
"I have never had to invoke a formula to fight oscillation in a guitar amp."- Enzo
Comment
-
I've often wondered about these tremolo oscillators that use a 25uF cap for cathode bypass. It seems to me that it would be unaffective at the lowest frequencies. I suggest you try something like 220uF. You can just tack it in place in parallel with the 25uF. Any cap 10V or higher would work.WARNING! Musical Instrument amplifiers contain lethal voltages and can retain them even when unplugged. Refer service to qualified personnel.
REMEMBER: Everybody knows that smokin' ain't allowed in school !
Comment
-
Originally posted by tubeswell View PostThose voltages look in the ballpark.
Maybe try a 120k tapering resistor between the pot wiper and the ground. Are the other resistors in the R-C part of the LFO stage 1M? Do you have .03uF for the first cap and .01 uF for the next two?
Apparently the 3M is in this design way too much and the tremolo kicks in at about 1.5M with a certain minimum speed. This is set by amongst others the three caps you mentioned. I changed the 2nd 0.01uF into 0.022uF and the neighbouring 0.03uF into 0.047uF. This actually slows the minimum speed down a bit, BUT at a similar pot dial position (about 4).
I still have the two 1M's. Is this related to the intensity or also the speed (offset)?
What about my suggestion of putting a 5M in parallel to the right and middle wiper as suggested in my previous post?
Comment
-
Originally posted by loudthud View PostI've often wondered about these tremolo oscillators that use a 25uF cap for cathode bypass. It seems to me that it would be unaffective at the lowest frequencies. I suggest you try something like 220uF. You can just tack it in place in parallel with the 25uF. Any cap 10V or higher would work.
Comment
-
Bypassing the cathode of a triode increases the gain about 6dB, but only down to a certain frequency. Increasing the capacitance lowers the frequency before the gain drops off.
The phase shift oscillator works by feeding the signal from the plate back to the grid through an RC network that shifts the phase 180 degrees. The RC network must not attenuate the signal amplitude too much or the tube will not oscillate. The tube needs to have enough gain so that together with the amount of attenuation of the RC network, enough signal gets back to the grid to cause oscillation. Note that the RC network only has 180 degrees of phase shift at one frequency. Above that frequency, there is less phase shift, below that frequency, there is more phase shift but also less signal that gets back to the grid.
So two things can cause the oscillator to stop oscillating. The gain of the tube being too low and too much attenuation in the RC network at the frequency where the phase shift is 180 degrees. The attenuation of the RC network changes as you adjust the 3 meg pot. The best way to evaluate the RC network is with a circuit modeling program because every capacitor (3) raises the order of the equasions. Generally try to keep all the capacitors about the same value.
One other thing that should be mentioned, that is the B+. In a tremolo amp such as this, there is quite a bit of the tremolo signal that gets on the B+ because the current of the output stage is changing. This acts against the oscillator like negative feedback. A symptom would be that oscillation stops or changes frequency when you turn up the Intensity control.
Tubes manufactured these days don't have quite as much gain as in previous decades. The one you have just might be low gain, try another brand. A low heater voltage will also cause the gain to be low. Check the heater voltage at the socket and check the socket for tight contact to the tube pins.WARNING! Musical Instrument amplifiers contain lethal voltages and can retain them even when unplugged. Refer service to qualified personnel.
REMEMBER: Everybody knows that smokin' ain't allowed in school !
Comment
-
Originally posted by klooon View Postplease have a look at my previous two posts with the graphs. please correct me if I am wrong, but the at slow/zero speed the 3M pot is at max with 160k in series.
Originally posted by klooon View PostTurning the dial up lowers the 3M and the remainder part is parallel wih the 160k. then I got the figures in the graphs and I notice that the 160k is just the limiting value at highest speed. at low speed it doesn't do much compared with the 3. in series in total.
* With a linear taper pot, you can assume even splits of resistance and rotation, but with an audio taper, the resistance at different rotations will be logarithmic, and different types audio pots can have different audio tapers, depending on how the taper was specified in the pot design.
Originally posted by klooon View PostApparently the 3M is in this design way too much and the tremolo kicks in at about 1.5M with a certain minimum speed. This is set by amongst others the three caps you mentioned. I changed the 2nd 0.01uF into 0.022uF and the neighbouring 0.03uF into 0.047uF. This actually slows the minimum speed down a bit, BUT at a similar pot dial position (about 4).
I still have the two 1M's. Is this related to the intensity or also the speed (offset)?
Originally posted by klooon View PostWhat about my suggestion of putting a 5M in parallel to the right and middle wiper as suggested in my previous post?Building a better world (one tube amp at a time)
"I have never had to invoke a formula to fight oscillation in a guitar amp."- Enzo
Comment
-
Originally posted by tubeswell View PostThe slow speed should be at the 'zero end' of the pot rotation, not the other way around. This position is where the resistance between the pot input terminal and the pot wiper terminal is the greatest. You're using 3MRA right? ( and not 3M?). If your pot is kicking in differently, you may have the input and output terminals the wrong way around on the pot. Have you tried swapping them around?
Originally posted by tubeswell View PostThe 160k is just altering the taper of the pot. With the pot at maximum rotation you have 160k and 3M in parallel,
Originally posted by tubeswell View Postand as you decrease the pot rotation you get increasing resistance between the pot wiper and the pot input (but the resistance between the pot ground and the pot wiper remains in parallel with the 160k - you can chart this on a spreadsheet if you measure the pot's actual taper* at various rotations first)
I think it's fine...
Originally posted by tubeswell View PostAltering either the capacitance or the resistance (or both) will alter the rate of oscillation.
Originally posted by tubeswell View PostThat will just be putting another resistance in parallel with the pot's input-to-ground resistance and would decrease the overall effectiveness of the pot in changing the speed.
---> I have 'measured' my minimum speed around 3 to 4 Hz (about 35 ticks in 10 seconds) ---> is this 'normal'?
BTW
- Do you have the original pot wiring with the taper resistor between the left lug and the wiper OR in series like the black faces?
- Does the original 5G9 have a linear taper and the 100k is making it more reverse log?
Last edited by klooon; 04-27-2012, 09:24 PM.
Comment
-
Thanks so much for the lecture!
Originally posted by loudthud View PostBypassing the cathode of a triode increases the gain about 6dB, but only down to a certain frequency. Increasing the capacitance lowers the frequency before the gain drops off.
I will order a 220uF and see what will happen!
Originally posted by loudthud View PostThe phase shift oscillator works by feeding the signal from the plate back to the grid through an RC network that shifts the phase 180 degrees. The RC network must not attenuate the signal amplitude too much or the tube will not oscillate. The tube needs to have enough gain so that together with the amount of attenuation of the RC network, enough signal gets back to the grid to cause oscillation. Note that the RC network only has 180 degrees of phase shift at one frequency. Above that frequency, there is less phase shift, below that frequency, there is more phase shift but also less signal that gets back to the grid.
So two things can cause the oscillator to stop oscillating. The gain of the tube being too low and too much attenuation in the RC network at the frequency where the phase shift is 180 degrees.
The attenuation of the RC network changes as you adjust the 3 meg pot. The best way to evaluate the RC network is with a circuit modeling program because every capacitor (3) raises the order of the equasions. Generally try to keep all the capacitors about the same value.
Originally posted by loudthud View PostOne other thing that should be mentioned, that is the B+. In a tremolo amp such as this, there is quite a bit of the tremolo signal that gets on the B+ because the current of the output stage is changing. This acts against the oscillator like negative feedback. A symptom would be that oscillation stops or changes frequency when you turn up the Intensity control.
Tubes manufactured these days don't have quite as much gain as in previous decades. The one you have just might be low gain, try another brand. A low heater voltage will also cause the gain to be low. Check the heater voltage at the socket and check the socket for tight contact to the tube pins.
I checked the heater voltages and they are at about 3.3 V
Comment
Comment