Are you measuring the blown IC? If there is continuity with cardboard between IC and heatsink (and screw removed), then the case of the IC is shorted to ground internally. You won't be able to check insulation with a bad IC.
Like JPB mentioned, in addition to the mica insulator, the screw must have the proper plastic insulating bushing.
Like JPB mentioned, in addition to the mica insulator, the screw must have the proper plastic insulating bushing.
Comment