Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Harley electronic speedometer help

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Harley electronic speedometer help

    Hi guys. Of course I realize this topic is not amp related, but I am having an electrical dilemma that would be more suited to a group of electronic guys than a group of motorcycle guys.

    Problem is with my electronic speedometer, which is known to have a pretty high failure rate around this era (mid 90's). It is an analog sweeping pointer type display on a round dial. It is a simple hook up. It receives a switched +12v from the ignition. It uses this to power the speedo internally, as well as a couple of incandescent lamps. It also splits this 12v and ground to send out on a three wire harness (red, blk, white) to the Vehicle Speed Sensor mounted on top of the transmission. This powers a Hall Sensor square wave signal relative to the speed of the teeth of a gear in the tranny. This signal is then fed back to the speedo on a white wire, where the speedo uses it to drive the powered speedo dial motor and odometer. It also works with the directionals to self cancel.

    My speedo acts a little nervously at times at idle with the bike not moving by twitching around a little between 0 - 4 mph Then after riding for perhaps 10 miles, the dial just drops dead to 0 mph, and the odometer stops counting. The directionals won't self cancel, but in this case that is to be expected. Vehicle speed seems not to be a factor, and as far as I can tell in the daylight, the 12v indicator bulbs stay lit. It aslo at this time seems to be heat related in that it usually works when setting out after sitting for a time, but at some point goes into failure yet once again.

    I wanted to see what the 12v was doing when riding, so I wired up a bright LED/resistor to the red wire that goes down to the new speed sensor that I just replaced. In this case, when the speedo dumped to 0 mph, the led stayed lit, telling me I had good supply voltage. And since the sensor voltage is fed from and thru the speedo, I assume the speedo is staying powered as well.

    Then I wanted more than what an LED could react to regarding voltage fluctuations, so I wired an analog panel mount dial gauge to that same red wire down under the seat going to the speed sensor. This allowed me to watch the speedo and the volt meter at the same time. But, when the speedo acted up, the volt meter did not. OK, good supply voltage.

    So now I get to my trouble area, measuring the square wave return pulse from the speed sensor. I want to know the same thing about it, what is the signal fed back to the speedo doing when the speedo dial drops dead while riding? I can raise the rear wheel of the bike with my o-scope on the white signal wire while the bike is in the garage, and hand spin the rear wheel in 5th gear to observe what the signal looks like. But this doesn't really tell me much from a riding perspective. Since I can't ride around with an o-scope hanging off the bike, I need some other, (crude as it may be), way to observe the square wave when the dial drops to zero. So far, I have not come to a solution for this, and don't want to go out and buy a hand held wave analyzer for this one job.

    So, who knows how to monitor this signal in a meaningful way on a motorcycle on the road in the sun? I know I could tie my Fluke to it, but this would give me only an ever changing numerical value, not really the visual I would like. I have ordered an Arduino based square wave generator to be able to feed the speedo from it to observe the dial, but again, it doesn't really tell me much regarding intermittant heat related failure on the road.

    If all this leads me to concur the speedo is in fact faulty, I have at least some hope held out that maybe I could crack this speedo open (possible, but difficult) to see if I could find what it seems might be connection based. Of course this also risks totalling the speedo, which given how difficult and expensive it would be to replace with either another used one, or aftermarket take your chances roll of the dice replacement, seems worth a try.

    I have included a basic drawing of the circuit.

    It's weird, because it WAS working fine.....

  • #2
    Hall effect sensors can go bad. I've replaced 2 cam posistion sensors on my nissan pathfinder.
    Here is a page that might help you go further.

    nosaj
    The Hall Effect Sensor is a small yet powerful device that plays a significant role in various electronic applications. Whether you're working on a DIY
    soldering stuff that's broken, breaking stuff that works, Yeah!

    Comment


    • #3
      So you have just replaced the sensor to try to correct the fault but it made no difference?
      Originally posted by Enzo
      I have a sign in my shop that says, "Never think up reasons not to check something."


      Comment


      • #4
        Have you cleaned the sensor and the other piece that signals the hall sensor? A cracked hall sensor will display funny stuff but the only way to tell is to use a magnetic photo card to see the magnet fields.
        nosaj
        soldering stuff that's broken, breaking stuff that works, Yeah!

        Comment


        • #5
          New sensor was installed very recently. I thought it corrected things, but it did not.

          The sensor is a solid one piece unit, it is not cracked. The transmission teeth that trigger the sensor are inaccessible without pulling the motor and cracking the cases.

          Anyway, I have already trouble shot all of that. What I want to know is if/how to read the square pulses while riding. I want to know what the pulses look like when the speedo is failing. If the pulses stop, then I go backwards to the sensor. If the pulses stay the same as delivered back to the speedo, then I have a sometimes failing speedo.

          Can you help me to figure out how to read the pulses while riding in sunlight? Something I can see easily without driving off the road?
          It's weird, because it WAS working fine.....

          Comment


          • #6
            I've often run into this kind of difficulty with bikes and lately I'm inclined to get a cheap handheld DSO - something like a Zeeweii DSO1511G or maybe something even cheaper. I don't know how readable they'd be in direct sunlight, but on a cloudy day they should be OK.

            I have an electronic tacho that's playing up - I'm inclined to think it's the unit itself but it could be noise on the sense line that's fed off one coil. It's crimped around the bezel and every one I've seen that's been taken apart has been damaged. I'd need to be convinced that it was faulty before I opened it up. My approach would be to make up a tool to properly unroll the bezel and be able to roll it back over. Pretty much the technique I use when rebuilding can capacitors but on a larger scale.

            Comment


            • #7
              I'm not sure what kind of frequencies you are dealing with for that square wave. Depending on that, a simple diode rectifier creating DC to run a LED might give you a visual indication of drop-outs.
              Originally posted by Enzo
              I have a sign in my shop that says, "Never think up reasons not to check something."


              Comment


              • #8
                Pretty sure a diode won't be fast enough for my needs. It goes high every time a gear tooth passes by, so pretty fast.
                It's weird, because it WAS working fine.....

                Comment


                • #9
                  Then maybe some kind of frequency counter, or electronic tach.
                  Originally posted by Enzo
                  I have a sign in my shop that says, "Never think up reasons not to check something."


                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Dang.

                    What I am asking is, does anyone know what "some kind of frequency counter" that would temporarily fit on a bike and run on 12v would actually be? I already have an electronic tach. It has a different job, and gets it's signal from another place.

                    I want to see the pulses while I am fact gathering while riding. Does anyone know if there is a way to do this?

                    BTW, I have a good Harley forum for bike troubleshooting, but we have dead ended with this. And you guys are the electronics guys, so let's keep the two separate please. Replacing the speedo, as others have suggested is about a $300 possible solution with no guarantees it will work without knowing what I am asking about where and in what condition the sensor pulses are. So fixing it would be preferable before going the other route.
                    Last edited by Randall; 08-03-2024, 09:31 PM.
                    It's weird, because it WAS working fine.....

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      how about this?.. I've used a digital tach for 2 cycle engines one wire you wrap it around a coil wire and it counts the pulses so you can tune the 2 cycle.
                      How about one of those powered by a coin cell take the one wire lead wrap it around the speedometer cable if signal is too weak make more wraps cause your just grabbing the signal by inductance. Maybe you can infer the data while its running?

                      nosaj
                      soldering stuff that's broken, breaking stuff that works, Yeah!

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        If you want to see the pulses, it's like Mick said in post #6, a handheld DSO.
                        But you said:
                        Originally posted by Randall View Post
                        don't want to go out and buy a hand held wave analyzer for this one job.
                        Does it look as if the speedo might come apart? Possibly there is a regulator or caps or solder or something simple that is responsible for all the failures.
                        Originally posted by Enzo
                        I have a sign in my shop that says, "Never think up reasons not to check something."


                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I have an inductive wrap tach on my other bike. I believe they are designed to use the pulses from a spark plug wire. I just don't see it working on induction from a 0-5v pulse.

                          The speedo will come apart with extreme prejudice and risk of destroying it, but it is a hack that was not part of the design. It is smd AFAIK, and without any documentation. But that would be my last intention if I can determine that the pulses are indeed getting back to the speedo circuitry. That would mean speedo problem, and at that point with not much to lose by taking a stab at cracking it open and seeing if I can correct something.

                          But, if it shows that the source pulses are dropping out when the speedo dies, then trying to open and fix it doesn't make sense at that point, because the issue would be lost pulses upstream of the speedo.

                          SO, reading those pulses is still where I am and what I am asking how to do. The expense of a handheld DSO is not really a realistic answer for me considering it could end up on top of the expense of a used vintage speedo. I was hoping for a cheaper and possibily less elegant solution. But, maybe there isn't one.

                          Except for the dangerous one of lifting and freeing the rear wheel, and looking at it with my bench scope while the bike is running in gear. But, even that dangerous approach isn't without flaws, as it often takes 10 miles or so on the road before it fails at speed. And failure mode is what I need to see.
                          It's weird, because it WAS working fine.....

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by Randall View Post
                            I have an inductive wrap tach on my other bike. I believe they are designed to use the pulses from a spark plug wire. I just don't see it working on induction from a 0-5v pulse.
                            .
                            Is that any reason to not try it?

                            nosaj

                            soldering stuff that's broken, breaking stuff that works, Yeah!

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Is this an OEM speedo or aftermarket?
                              The attached page may be of interest.
                              There seem to be a fair few threads about this already, so I hope this can bring a bunch of information together so anyone can get an understanding of how their tacho works, and more importantly how to fix it if it doesn't. What do they do? A tacho (or correctly a tachometer) give you an indication of the speed an engine is running (usually in RPM). How do they work? They are fed an electrical signal from your ignition system or ECU, the frequency of which is directly proportional to
                              soldering stuff that's broken, breaking stuff that works, Yeah!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X